Use cases/Software·8 min read

How does a planning software company get shortlisted when CFOs ask an assistant first?

What Throughline reads, finds and drafts for a budgeting, forecasting or consolidation platform sold to finance leaders, and which of its numbers move.

Gaurav RajBy Gaurav Raj · Founder, Throughline · Stockholm
Finance and planning softwareSoftware
On the listwhen a CFO asks an assistant for planning software
Named, by CFO questionPlanning software that works with our ERP: named by one assistant of four.
Namedfor the ERP the buyer already runs
Same weekfrom a webinar to its clips and follow-ups

A planning software company gets shortlisted when CFOs ask an assistant first by being on the pages those answers are built from (the comparison sites, the review grids, the lists of planning tools for a company of a given size) and by answering, on its own site, the exact questions a finance leader asks before a demo. Throughline reads where the company is named every week, for which questions and from which pages, and drafts the work that puts it on the list.

This page is for a company of twenty to two hundred people selling budgeting, forecasting, consolidation or reporting software to finance teams in mid-sized companies and groups. The product is strong and the customers stay for years. The buyer is a CFO or a head of finance who has run the same spreadsheets for a decade, asks a peer and an assistant before talking to anyone, and plans the purchase around the budget season. In the broad answers, the large suites are named first. The founders sell, the marketing team is small or still being hired, and the company’s best proof sits in customer conversations nobody has written down.

Where is the company named, question by question?

A finance leader does not ask for the company by name. They ask what to use, and the answer decides who gets a demo. This is the shape of it across the questions that come before a shortlist.

Named, by CFO question and assistantOne week of answers
ChatGPTClaudeGeminiPerplexity
Planning software for a mid-sized groupBudget season
Planning software that works with our ERP
Replace spreadsheets for budgetingEvery autumn
Rolling forecast tool for a finance team of five
Group consolidation without a big suite
Planning software with support in our language
Named firstNamedNot named

What does Throughline read for a planning software company?

The company’s own record first. The CRM gives every demo, opportunity and the source each buyer named; product analytics shows which trial accounts built a first budget and how far they went; Search Console shows category searches set against branded ones; the webinar platform shows who registered, who watched and for how long; and LinkedIn shows which of the founders’ posts finance leaders engaged with.

Then the questions. The weekly watch asks ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Perplexity what a finance leader asks before a shortlist: which planning tool suits a company of their size, which works with the ERP they already run, whether it is worth leaving spreadsheets, how a rolling forecast is set up, what it costs to switch. It asks in each language the company’s buyers use. It records who is named, in what order, and which pages each answer leans on.

And the calendar. Finance teams look at planning tools when the budget cycle starts and sign before the next one, so the weeks before budget season are when being on the list is worth the most. The scouts watch the category: a rival’s launch, a list that gets updated, a new integration a buyer will ask about.

What does it find when CFOs ask an assistant?

The findings are about the questions, not the brand: which ones put the company on the list, which ones leave it off, and what moved with demos. Each one says which tools it was read from and the one thing that could make it wrong.

Worth a lookWatchlist

The company is named when a question gives the company size, and missing when it names the buyer’s ERP; those answers quote integration pages where it has none.

Read from
Could make us wrongAnswers to broad questions change slowly, and a month is a short read.
Draft: a page for each ERP the product connects to, and briefing notes for the two lists the answers quote
Throughline foundHigh confidence

Demo requests from finance leaders moved with the weeks the budgeting webinar recordings were watched past the halfway mark.

Read from
Could make us wrongBudget season lifts demos across the category, whatever one company does.
Draft: three clips from the webinar, and a follow-up to everyone who watched past the half
Worth a lookWatchlist

Searches for replacing spreadsheets in budgeting rose through September, and the company’s page on it is not among the pages the answers quote.

Read from
Could make us wrongSearches rise every autumn as budgets start, so part of the rise is the season.
Draft: a page that answers the switch from spreadsheets directly, built around a customer story

What do the agents draft to get on the list?

The work that puts the company on the list: a page for each question a finance leader asks before a demo, with the integration pages first; a current entry and a briefing for each comparison site and list the answers quote; customer stories in the numbers a CFO cares about, written with the customer and sent to them for approval; review requests to finance teams after year-end close; clips from the webinars; and posts the founders can publish under their own names. A person approves each piece. Nothing is published or sent without that yes.

Every page is tested against the questions finance leaders ask before it goes live, and read again a week later.

One Monday’s draftsWaiting for a yes
  • PagePlanning with our ERP, answered for the first system$6.40
  • PageLeaving spreadsheets, built around a customer story$6.40
  • BriefBriefing notes for two lists the answers quote$2.60
  • EmailReview requests to finance teams after close$4.20
  • Video45s from the budgeting webinar$10.80
  • SocialFive posts for the founders, from the webinar$1.50
6 drafts · 0 sent without a yes$31.90

That is one week’s queue. If a draft takes more runs to get right, those runs are on us, never on the bill.

Which numbers move, and by how much?

A planning software company is rarely missing everywhere. It is named for the questions its customers already use to describe it, and missing for the ones a new buyer asks: the ERP they run, the spreadsheets they want to leave, the language they work in. Those are the questions that decide a shortlist, and they move when the company has a page that answers each one and a current entry on the pages the answers quote. Over two quarters the company goes from named for a few questions to named for most of the ones it wins on, in time for the next budget season. How fast depends on how many of the quoted pages accept updates.

The numbers finance and planning software runs on
The numberHow it movesWhat the size of the move depends on
Named in answers to CFO planning questionsRises question by question, starting with the ERP and company-size questionsHow many of the quoted lists accept vendor updates
Named first for the questions the product wins onFollows once the company’s own pages answer them directlyHow much customer proof can be published
Demos that say they came from an assistant or a peerRecorded on every demo, and rising with the listWhether the demo form asks the question
Reviews by count and recencyThe gap closes on recency first, then on countHow many customers are asked after their year-end close
Time from a webinar to its clips and follow-upsFrom weeks to the same weekWhether the recording is shared the day it ends

The large suites are on the list because they are on the pages the assistants read. Those pages are open to any company that keeps them current.

What happens in the first thirty days?

  1. Week 1Throughline reads the CRM, product analytics, search and the webinar platform, and starts the weekly watch of what finance leaders are told.
  2. Week 2The first briefing: each CFO question, who is named, in what order, and which pages told the assistant so.
  3. Week 3The first integration page, the first comparison briefings and the webinar clips are drafted and approved.
  4. Week 4The first receipt: what shipped, what it cost, what moved.

Questions people ask

Our buyers are CFOs. Do they really ask an assistant?

Some start there and some ask a peer. Throughline does not assume either: the weekly watch shows what the assistants say, and the demo form records where each buyer started.

We sell in more than one language. Does the watch cover that?

Yes. The questions are asked in each language your buyers use, and the findings show where an answer in one language names you and the same answer in another does not.

Does this replace a marketing hire?

No. It gives a marketing lead, new or long in the seat, the reading and the first drafts from the first week, so their time goes to the decisions only they can make.

Who on our team approves the work?

Usually a founder or the marketing lead, with sales seeing the comparison pages before they go live. Every approval happens in one queue.

Where do we start?

With the Visibility Report: a week of the questions finance leaders ask, who is named and from which pages. The call after it sets the scope.

The shortlist is written before the demo. Be on it.